User talk:MarcelTheHippie

To prevent this little ping pong, lets talk here. Images relevant to a single city don't belong on a server-wide timeline page. They don't fit with the theme and tone of the other images, nor should they be displayed so prominently. Editing for editing sake is unneeded on a page like that. --  Hirudo6

I think otherwise. Kurai Cho is one of the most prominent places on the server, and the image above those two then/now images is only relevant to the Spawn area. Furthermore, it can be quite helpful to show how a particular location has changed and evolved over time; after all, it is a timeline page! MarcelTheHippie 01:55, 24 November 2018 (UTC)

Kurai Cho is one of many. If you really think they deserve a place, put them on the bottom in a gallery -- Hirudo6

Kurai Cho isn't that prominent and not enough to be at the top of the timeline page, there are already pictures on that page showing how spawn and the overall map have changed over time. The Kurai Cho ones can be on the page for that town but it does not seem like it should be at the top of the timeline page. There are plenty of other images which show how a place has changed over time. The ones of spawn are more fitting for the timeline page. I also believe the timeline page doesn't even mention Kurai Cho, so it seems even more out of place. Anna 28 05:02, 24 November 2018 (UTC)

I personally disagree with regards to prominence. And those two images are the only ones I know of that show the progression of time from near-identical ingame viewpoints, which makes them even more unique. MarcelTheHippie 15:27, 26 November 2018 (UTC)

Unique does not make them suitable for an overview page of the whole server: only general events or certain spawn builds (such as Flippeh statue) do belong on the page. Agree or disagree, there is no use in trying to get your point through here. Want those pictures on the wiki? Put them on the page concerned. LewisD95 18:28, 26 November 2018 (UTC)

You talk as though Kurai Cho is on a completely different server, which it obviously isn't. Seriously though, what's wrong with having more variety location-wise? There's nothing which says that ingame screenshots on that article should only be of the spawn area. I also have the impression that you and Anna are disagreeing with me because Hirudo did and you're all just jumping on the bandwagon. MarcelTheHippie 22:10, 26 November 2018 (UTC)

You're out of order. Anna made a decision and you're still trying to fight it. --  Hirudo6

If the page even mentioned Kurai Cho, then it would be suitable. And relating to identical view-points, you could always go find an old image then take a new one from the same view. Anna 28 00:14, 27 November 2018 (UTC)